We spun the virtual wheel for “Netflix Roulette” and wound up with a movie we had trouble approaching: 2015’s “The Gift.” What at first seems like a “creepy guy starts getting too close to the nice couple” thriller begins to take unexpected turns as the wife starts digging into the creepy guy’s past. The tone of the film is odd, and gets darker and more unsettling as it goes along. Join David, Brett, and Nicole as they ponder things like, Is this the most horrifying movie we’ve watched? How does Jason Bateman’s character get his influence? Does the punishment at the end fit the crime? And will we ever look at a monkey the same way again?

Connect with your hosts! Brett Stewart | Nicole Davis | David Luzader